A great way to experience pipe tobacco without losing the pleasure of a cigar. I liked the Plum Pudding cigar a lot, nice change of pace. My only other experience with cigars containing pipe tobacco was the Stillwell Star line from Dunbarton. My favorite STILLWELL Star is the Bayou32.. I personally thought the Plum Pudding had more flavors and showcased the pipe tobacco better. That said I wouldn’t be disappointed with either one.